FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Civil Justice Advocate Calls on Penn Station Task Force to Push For Action on Labor Law Reform


Contact: Phoebe Stonbely | | 518-512-5265


Scaffold Law’ a financial drain on infrastructure dollars

“statute carries archaic liability rules that exist nowhere else in the nation

Albany, NY – Today, Tom Stebbins, Executive Director of the Lawsuit Reform Alliance of New York sent a letter urging the newly formed Penn Station Task Force to support reforming the costly liability rules under the state’s controversial ‘Scaffold Law.’

“The statute carries archaic liability rules that exist nowhere else in the nation,” wrote Stebbins, “contractors and property owners – including the state and public authorities – face 100% liability in lawsuits for gravity-related construction accidents, even if the party had nothing to do with the accident.”

“The state’s crumbling infrastructure cannot continue to suffer under this imbalanced law. We urge you to make Scaffold Law reform a priority,” he continued.

Earlier this year, Assemblymember John McDonald (D-Cohoes) introduced A.5624, a concise and comprehensive bill aimed at solving the liability crisis created by the law.

“I see very quickly that New York State is losing its competitive advantage,” Assemblymember McDonald said as he addressed the attendees of the Scaffold Law Reform Coalition’s annual lobby day in Albany this past February.

According to the memo accompanying the bill, the legislation “will provide much needed relief to school districts, counties, and local governments by lowering their liability exposure and creating significant savings on all infrastructure construction projects in New York State.”

“Most importantly,” the memo concludes, the proposed reform “would not weaken the law’s safety provisions.”

Louis J. Coletti, President & CEO, Building Trades Employers’ Association told the press in 2016, “the trial attorneys have been the 4th branch of state government for far too long. Reform for them isn’t about worker safety—it is about the money they earn in §240 cases”

At 2016’s Scaffold Law Reform Day, Jolie Milstein, President & CEO of the New York State Association for Affordable Housing (NYSAFAH) said, “New York is facing a statewide housing crisis and the Scaffold Law is standing in the way of more affordable housing for low- and middle-income families and seniors.”

Similarly, in March of 2017, Habitat for Humanity of New York State President and CEO, Judith Nelson wrote to Governor Cuomo and legislative leaders in support of McDonald’s bill: “Due to the Scaffold Law’s ‘absolute liability’ standard, no insurer would write the policy to cover our volunteers…We urge you to consider changing these archaic laws and assist affordable housing providers with more viable and economical solutions to the housing needs of New York families.”

Scaffold Law reform is supported by a diverse coalition including the New York State Association for Affordable Housing, New York State School Boards Association, New York State Farm Bureau, Business Council of New York State, the New York Conference of Mayors, Associated General Contractors, Unshackle Upstate, National Federation of Independent Businesses, the Manufacturers Association, and chambers of commerce across the state.

See letter to Penn Station Task Force here:


The Lawsuit Reform Alliance of New York (LRANY) is a nonpartisan not-for-profit association of businesses, professionals, healthcare providers, membership organizations, taxpayers, and concerned citizens committed to changing New York’s legal system to help create jobs and energize our economy.

Gotham Gazette: The ‘Worst State for Doctors’ Has a Dangerous Pre-existing Condition

The Gotham Gazette has published an opinion article from LRANY’s Executive Director, Tom Stebbins: The ‘Worst State for Doctors’ Has a Dangerous Pre-existing Condition. The article points to the medical liability crisis New York has been facing for too long and simple changes to fix this ailing issue.

An excerpt:

“Another year, and another report naming New York the “Worst State for Doctors.” Time and time again, our state ranks dead last as a place for physicians to practice.

The primary reason for the Empire State’s strained relationship with the medical profession is the staggering cost of medical liability insurance. New York has the highest per capita medical liability payouts in the country. These payouts are 35 times higher, per capita, than they are in the lowest state. Nearly 20 percent of all the medical liability payouts in the U.S. are paid in New York, more than all of the medical liability payouts for the entire Midwest.”

Read the full article here

New Yorkers Money: Wa$ted

NYC Tort Claims FY 2015

NY Job-Juicer

post letter job juicer

Great Articles!

We’re thrilled that even more people are paying attention to our efforts to reform New York’s antiquated lawsuit system.  Click here to see an “advertorial” which recently ran in The Capitol magazine and click here to see a column which ran in the Albany Times Union.

There’s more big news coming about our organization.  Stay tuned!